How Good Is 5% a Month? Bob's Bots vs. the Greatest Trading Records
5% a month sounds modest. Compounded, it is about 79.6% a year. Below, the best-known long-term records in investing are converted to the same "per month" figure, so you can see where 5% sits. Our own figures are backtests (hypothetical), not live track records. Read the caveats below the table before comparing them.
What monthly returns compound to
Why 100% a month isn't realistic: doubling every month turns $1,000 into about $4.1 million in a year and about $16.8 billion in two. The strongest record in the table, Medallion, had its best year at +152% before fees for the whole year, and it was capped at about $10 billion because markets can't absorb more. If a product promises 100% a month, treat that as a red flag.
Average month, compounded equivalent
The records, side by side
Per month = (1 + annual)1/12 − 1. Figures are as reported by each source; periods and fee treatment differ, so this is context rather than a like-for-like ranking.
| Who | Annual | Period | Per month | Max drawdown | Fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Richard Dennis's "Turtle" traders[2] Average of the trainees' compounded returns over a short window; individual records varied widely. | 80.0% | ~1984–1988 (~4½ yrs) | 5.02% | Not stated | Mostly before fees |
| Renaissance Medallion (before fees)[1] Compounded; arithmetic average 66.1%. Closed to outsiders; capped around $10B. | 63.3% | 1988–2018 (31 yrs) | 4.17% | Never a losing year before fees | Before fees |
| Ed Seykota (one client account)[3] $5,000 grew over 250,000% (cash-on-cash, after withdrawals). One account, as told to the author; not an audited fund record. | 63.1% | 1972–1988 (16 yrs) | 4.16% | Not stated | Not stated |
| Renaissance Medallion (after fees)[1] Compounded from the yearly net returns in the same table (arithmetic average 39.2%). | 37.8% | 1988–2018 (31 yrs) | 2.71% | Worst year −3.2% (1989) | After 5% + 20–44% fees |
| Peter Lynch, Fidelity Magellan[4][5] Assets grew from ~$18M to ~$14B during his tenure. | 29.2% | 1977–1990 (13 yrs) | 2.16% | Not stated | Fund returns (fee basis not stated) |
| Bitcoin, buy and hold[17] Very sensitive to the start date: from end-2018 it was ~57%/yr. | 26.1% | end-2017 to end-2025 (8 yrs) | 1.95% | −83% (Dec 2017–Dec 2018), −77% (Nov 2021–Nov 2022) | Price only |
| George Soros, Quantum Fund[6][7] "About 20% a year on average"; Bloomberg put it at 35% a year for 1969–1995. | 20.0% | 1969–2011 (42 yrs) | 1.53% | Not stated | Not stated |
| Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway (stock)[8][9] Per-share market value, compounded. | 19.8% | 1965–2023 (59 yrs) | 1.52% | −59.1% (1973–75), −50.7% (2008–09) | Shareholder return (no fund fees) |
| Paul Tudor Jones, Tudor BVI Global[10] "Close to 19.5 percent" long-term, per material given to investors. | 19.5% | 1986–2013 (~27 yrs) | 1.50% | Only down year −4.9% (2008) | Not stated |
| Citadel Wellington (Ken Griffin)[11] Multi-strategy fund running tens of billions. | 19.0% | 1990–2025 (35 yrs) | 1.46% | Not stated | Net of fees |
| DUNN Capital WMA (trend following)[12][13] One of the longest-running trend-following CTAs. | 14.6% | 1984–2011 (27 yrs) | 1.14% | −60.3% (from 2003) | Not stated |
| D.E. Shaw Composite Fund[14] Largest multi-strategy fund of D.E. Shaw. | 12.9% | 2001–2025 (25 yrs) | 1.02% | Not stated | Net of fees |
| Winton Futures Fund (David Harding)[15] Systematic trend following. | 12.7% | 1997–Feb 2017 (20 yrs) | 1.00% | Not stated | Not stated |
| Bridgewater Pure Alpha (18% vol)[15][16] World's largest hedge fund firm. | 12.3% | 1991–Feb 2017 (26 yrs) | 0.97% | Not stated | Not stated (Forbes/LCH: 13% net to 2015) |
| Man AHL Alpha[15] Systematic multi-market program. | 11.6% | 1994–Feb 2017 (23 yrs) | 0.92% | Not stated | Not stated |
| S&P 500 with dividends[8] Buy and hold the US stock market. | 10.2% | 1965–2023 (59 yrs) | 0.81% | Worst calendar year −37.0% (2008) | Index (no fees) |
| Two-Bot Portfolio: Relative Strength + Volume Breakout (Aggressive) Bob's Bots template, backtest (hypothetical), after modelled fees, slippage and funding. Out-of-sample: +5.02%/mo. | 85% | 2019-09-08 to 2026-11-19 (common period of both bots) | 5.24% | -39.7% (backtest) | After modelled costs; not live |
| Volume-Confirmed Breakout (Aggressive) Bob's Bots template, backtest (hypothetical), after modelled fees, slippage and funding. Out-of-sample: +4.89%/mo. | 64% | 2019-09-08 to 2026-11-19 | 4.23% | -47.7% (backtest) | After modelled costs; not live |
| Relative Strength Long/Short (Aggressive) Bob's Bots template, backtest (hypothetical), after modelled fees, slippage and funding. Out-of-sample: +3.96%/mo. | 89% | 2019-09-08 to 2026-11-19 | 5.43% | -49.4% (backtest) | After modelled costs; not live |
| Two-Bot Portfolio: Relative Strength (Aggressive) + Bollinger Breakout Bob's Bots template, backtest (hypothetical), after modelled fees, slippage and funding. Out-of-sample: +3.60%/mo. | 71% | 2019-09-08 to 2026-11-19 (common period of both bots) | 4.56% | -27.9% (backtest) | After modelled costs; not live |
| Relative Strength + Trend (Aggressive) Bob's Bots template, backtest (hypothetical), after modelled fees, slippage and funding. Out-of-sample: +3.42%/mo. | 53% | 2019-09-08 to 2026-11-19 | 3.62% | -45.7% (backtest) | After modelled costs; not live |
Why our backtests aren't the same as these records
- Hypothetical vs. real. A backtest knows the rules in advance and never has to sit through a loss with real money. Even with out-of-sample tests and luck checks, live results are usually worse.
- Size. The funds above managed billions; Medallion was capped at about $10 billion. A small account can trade smaller, faster markets than a large fund can, which is one reason small-scale backtests can look much higher. It also means results can fall as more money uses the same idea.
- Short history. Our tests cover crypto perpetual futures from 2019 to 2026, about seven years. Many records above cover decades and several crises.
- Drawdowns. Our templates fell -40%, -48%, -49%, -28%, -46% from their peaks in testing. Buffett's Berkshire fell 59% in 1973–75 and 51% in 2008–09. Big losses happen even to the best.
- Nothing is guaranteed. Past results, real or backtested, do not predict future results.
Questions
Is 5% a month a lot?
Yes. 5% a month compounds to about 79.6% a year. Over long periods, the best-known funds and investors in the table compounded between roughly 0.8% and 4.2% a month, and most were between 1% and 2.2%.
Are Bob's Bots results real track records?
No. Our numbers are backtests: hypothetical results from running rules on past data after modelled fees, slippage and funding. They are not audited live results, and live results are usually worse than backtests.
Why can't a bot make 100% a month?
100% a month means doubling every month: about 4,096 times your money in a year. Even Medallion's best year in its published record was +152% before fees for the whole year, and no market has enough liquidity to absorb returns like that for long.
Why compare with funds that ran billions?
For context only. Big funds are limited by their size; a small account can trade small, fast markets that a $10 billion fund cannot. That helps small accounts, but it does not make backtest results a promise.
Sources
- Cornell, "Medallion Fund: The Ultimate Counterexample?" (2019), using data from Zuckerman, The Man Who Solved the Market (2019), Appendix 1 — www.cornell-capital.com
- Curtis Faith, Way of the Turtle (McGraw-Hill, 2007), Introduction; the Wall Street Journal reported the same ~80% compounded figure on Sep 5, 1989
- Jack D. Schwager, Market Wizards (1989), chapter on Ed Seykota
- Wharton Magazine, "Stock Superstar Who Beat The Street: Peter S. Lynch" — magazine.wharton.upenn.edu
- PBS Frontline, interview with Peter Lynch ($1,000 in May 1977 became $28,000 by May 1990) — www.pbs.org
- The Guardian, "George Soros to close hedge fund management group to outside investors" (Jul 26, 2011) — www.theguardian.com
- Bloomberg Businessweek, "Soros: Anatomy Of A Comeback" (Sep 24, 1995) — www.bloomberg.com
- Berkshire Hathaway 2023 shareholder letter, performance table — www.berkshirehathaway.com
- Berkshire Hathaway 2017 shareholder letter ("four truly major dips") — www.berkshirehathaway.com
- The New York Times via CNBC, "After a Dazzling Early Career, a Star Trader Settles Down" (Mar 6, 2014) — www.cnbc.com
- CNBC, "Ken Griffin's flagship hedge fund at Citadel rises 10.2% in volatile 2025" (Jan 2, 2026) — www.cnbc.com
- WealthBriefing, "Veteran Commodity, Financial Fund Gets A UCITS Makeover" (May 11, 2011) — www.wealthbriefing.com
- CTA Database (FundPeak) factsheet, DUNN WMA program — ctadatabase.fundpeak.com
- Reuters, "Top hedge funds led by D.E. Shaw, Bridgewater and Balyasny deliver big gains in 2025" (Jan 2, 2026) — www.reuters.com
- Institutional Investor, "Red-Hot Quant Funds Cool Off" (Mar 29, 2017), citing Société Générale data — www.institutionalinvestor.com
- Forbes, "Billionaire Ray Dalio Has Produced More Dollar Gains Than Any Other Hedge Fund Manager Ever" (Jan 26, 2016), citing LCH Investments — www.forbes.com
- Binance BTCUSDT daily closes (public market-data API); our calculation — api.binance.com
Outside figures checked 2026-11-19. Bob's Bots figures update automatically from our latest baked backtests. See all tested templates · How we test · Disclaimers